National Player of the Year (High School)
| Year | Name | High School |
|---|---|---|
| 2018 | Kenzie Knuckles | Yorktown |
| 2014 | Carly Skjodt | Carmel |
| 2008 | Darcy Dorton | Delta |
| 1992 | Sacha Caldemeyer | Muncie Burris |
High School All-Americans
| Year | Name | High School |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 (Max Preps) | Charlotte Vinson | Yorktown |
| 2021 (Max Preps) | Eva Hudson | Bishop Dwenger |
| 2020 (Max Preps) | Elle Stinson | Yorktown |
| 2020 (Max Preps) | Mabrey Shaffmaster | New Castle |
| 2019 (Max Preps) | Melani Shaffmaster | New Castle |
| 2019 (Max Preps) | Mabrey Shaffmaster | New Castle |
| 2018 (Max Preps) | Melani Shaffmaster | New Castle |
| 2018 (Max Preps) | Kenzie Knuckles | Yorktown |
| 2017 (MaxPreps National Sophomore of the Year) | Melani Shaffmaster | New Castle |
| 2017 (Max Preps) | Melani Shaffmaster | New Castle |
| 2017 (MaxPreps National Freshman of the Year) | Mabrey Shaffmaster | New Castle |
| 2017 (MaxPreps Small Schools All-American) | Megan Miller | Alexandria Monroe |
| 2017 (MaxPreps Small Schools All-American) | Jonni Parker | Miami East, OH |
| 2016 (Prepvolleyball National Freshman of the Year) | Melani Shaffmaster | New Castle |
| 2016 (Max Preps) | Nia Parker-Robinson | Cathedral |
| 2014 (Max Preps) | Tionna Williams | Fort Wayne Concordia |
| 2014 (Max Preps) | Carly Skjodt | Carmel |
| 2014 (Max Preps) | Beth Prince | Avon |
| 2013 (Max Preps, Prep Volleyball) | Carly Skjodt | Carmel |
| 2013 (AVCA, Max Preps, Prep Volleyball) | Lauryn Gillis | New Castle |
| 2012 (Prep Volleyball) | Lauryn Gillis | New Castle |
| 2012 (Prep Volleyball) | Carly Skjodt | Carmel |
| 2011 (AVCA, ESPNHS, Max Preps, Prep Volleyball) | Taylor Morey | Muncie Burris |
| 2011 (Prep Volleyball) | Taylor Richardson | Wapahani |
| 2011 (Max Preps, Prep Volleyball) | Emily Wolfert | Yorktown |
| 2011 (Prep Volleyball) | Morgan Bergren | Delta |
| 2010 (Prep Volleyball) | Jamie Drummer | Muncie Central |
| 2010 (Prep Volleyball) | Alyssa Winner | Fort Lormaine, OH |
| 2010 (Prep Volleyball) | Alex Fuelling | Bellmont |
| 2010 (Max Preps, Prep Volleyball) | Taylor Morey | Muncie Burris |
| 2009 (AVCA) | Taylor Unroe | Muncie Burris |
| 2008 (AVCA) | Christina Gray | Cathedral |
| 2008 (AVCA) | Mary Ording | Cathedral |
| 2008 (AVCA) | Darcy Dorton | Delta |
| 2006 (AVCA) | Kim Kuzma | Muncie Central |
| 1996 (Volleyball Monthly) | Christi Girton | Muncie Central |
| 1995 (Volleyball Monthly) | Sara Sorrell | Muncie Central |
| 1993 (Volleyball Monthly) | Angie Harris | Bishop Luers |
| 1992 (Volleyball Monthly) | Kim Krull | Bellmont |
| 1992 (Volleyball Monthly) | Angie Kammer | Muncie Burris |
| 1992 (Volleyball Monthly) | Sacha Caldemeyer | Muncie Burris |
| 1990 (Volleyball Monthly) | Angie Breitenfield | Muncie Burris |
| 1988 (Reebok) | Sheri Stout | Muncie Burris |
Under Armour All-American
| Year | Name | High School |
|---|---|---|
| 2019 (First Team) | Melani Shaffmaster | New Castle High School |
| 2019 (Second Team) | MJ Hammill | Center Grove High School |
| 2019 (Honorable Mention) | Lauren Gilliland | Coldwater High School, Ohio |
| 2018 (Second Team) | Alyiah Wells | Briarcrest Christian School |
| 2018 (Second Team) | Kylie Murr | Yorktown High School |
| 2018 (Honorable Mention) | Rose Duffy | Fishers High School |
| 2017 (Honorable Mention) | Megan Miller | Alexandria Monroe High School |
| 2017 (Second Team) | Darian Goins | Avon High School |
| 2017 (First Team) | Jonni Parker | Miami East High School |
| 2016 (Second Team) | Nia Parker-Robinson | Cathedral |
| 2014 (First Team) | Carly Skjodt | Carmel |
| 2014 (First Team) | Tionna Williams | Fort Wayne Concordia |
| 2013 (First Team) | Lauryn Gillis | New Castle |
| 2009 (First Team) | Taylor Morey | Muncie Burris |
Under Armour All-American Game MVP
| Year | Name | High School |
|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Carly Skjodt | Carmel |
| 2013 | Lauryn Gillis | New Castle |
Gatorade Player Of The Year (Indiana)
| Year | Name | High School |
|---|---|---|
| 2020 | Melani Shaffmaster | New Castle |
| 2019 | Kenzie Knuckles | Yorktown |
| 2018 | Alyiah Wells | Briarcrest Christian School (Tennessee) |
| 2017 | Melani Shaffmaster | New Castle High School |
| 2017 | Jonni Parker | Miami East High School (Ohio) |
| 2016 | Nia Parker-Robinson | Cathedral |
| 2015 | Kendall White | Cathedral |
| 2014 | Carly Skjodt | Carmel |
| 2013 | Lauryn Gillis | New Castle |
| 2012 | Emily Wolfert | Yorktown |
| 2011 | Taylor Morey | Muncie Burris |
| 2010 | Taylor Unroe | Muncie Burris |
| 2009 | Darcy Dorton | Delta |
| 2008 | Caitlyn Cox | New Castle |
| 2005 | Danita Merlau | Cathedral |
| 2003 | Amanda McCormick | Muncie Burris |
| 1998 | Erica Meyers | Muncie Burris |
| 1997 | Christine Girton | Muncie Central |
| 1996 | Sara Sorrell | Muncie Central |
College All-Americans
| Year | Name | College |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 | Jonni Parker | Penn State |
| 2021 | Skyler Van Note | Marian |
| 2020 | Skyler Van Note | Marian |
| 2019 | Skyler Van Note | Marian |
| 2019 | Kendall White | Penn State |
| 2018 | Lauren Bruns | University of Dayton |
| 2018 | Ana Collar | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| 2018 | Jackie Quade | University of Illinois |
| 2018 | Carly Skjodt | University of Michigan |
| 2018 | E'Laisah Young | College of Southern Idaho |
| 2018 | Kendall White | Penn State |
| 2018 | Jonni Parker | Penn State |
| 2017 | Lindi Thomas | IU Kokomo |
| 2017 | Lauren Bruns | Ohio State |
| 2017 | Jesse Earl | Auburn |
| 2017 | Kendall White | Penn State |
| 2017 | Carly Skjodt | Michigan |
| 2017 | Tionna Williams | Wisconsin |
| 2016 | Tionna Williams | Wisconsin |
| 2014 | Morgan Bergren | Kentucky |
| 2014 | Taylor Morey | Wisconsin |
| 2009 | Sarah Rumely | Kentucky |
| 2005 | Melissa Elmer | Nebraska |
| 2004 | Lynette Moster | Georgia Tech |
| 2004 | Melissa Elmer | Nebraska |
| 2004 | Erin Heffner | Alabama |
| 2003 | Lynette Moster | Georgia Tech |
| 2003 | Erin Heffner | Alabama |
| 2002 | Lynette Moster | Georgia Tech |
| 1996 | Sacha Caldemeyer | University of Pacific |
| 1995 | Angie Breitenfield | Texas |
| 1988 | Dawn Davenport | Texas |
National Freshman of the Year (College)
| Year | Name | College |
|---|---|---|
| 1993 | Kim Krull | UCLA |
National Player Of The Year (College)
| Year | Name | College |
|---|---|---|
| 1998 | Dawn Davenport | Texas |
Special Awards
| Year | Name | College |
|---|---|---|
| 1990 ((U.S. Olympic Festival Gold Medal (Minnesota)) | Sheri Stout | Indiana |
| 1989 ((Big Ten Freshman of the Year)) | Sheri Stout | Indiana |